HeyPsych
Find SupportPractice ArchitectBrowseSearch

If you're in crisis, help is available 24/7

Call or text 988|More resources
HeyPsych

Better mental health starts with better decisions.

Learn about our clinical review process

Explore

  • Conditions
  • Treatments
  • Tools
  • Find Care

Resources

  • Learn
  • Assessments
  • Support & Crisis
  • For Clinicians

Company

  • About
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Contact

© 2026 HeyPsych. All rights reserved.

HeyPsych provides decision-support information. Not a substitute for professional medical advice.

Tools/Compare

Mentaya vs American Professional Agency

Show:
Detail:
Attribute
Billing

Mentaya

malpractice-insurance

American Professional Agency

American Professional Agency Inc.

Mentaya
American Professional Agency
Key Differencesat a glance
Mentaya:Offers a free tier
Mentaya:Purpose-built for mental health
American Professional Agency:Purpose-built for mental health

Overview

Tool Name
Mentaya
American Professional Agency
Tool Name
Mentaya
Mentaya
American Professional Agency
American Professional Agency
What It Is
Free out-of-network claims submission for therapists with 5% client fee and 100% refund guarantee on failed claims.
Specialized malpractice insurance for mental health and social service professionals since 1978.
What It Is
Mentaya
Free out-of-network claims submission for therapists with 5% client fee and 100% refund guarantee on failed claims.
American Professional Agency
Specialized malpractice insurance for mental health and social service professionals since 1978.
Primary Category
billing-rcm-insurance
malpractice-insurance
Primary Category
Mentaya
billing-rcm-insurance
American Professional Agency
malpractice-insurance
Founded
Unknown
Unknown
Founded
Mentaya
Unknown
American Professional Agency
Unknown
Best For
Out-of-network therapists wanting free claims submission; Practices seeking guaranteed claim success or refund; Therapists wanting to offer OON benefits without superbills
LCSWs, LMFTs, and LPCs seeking competitive rates; Clinicians with multiple licenses or specialties; Group practices needing entity coverage
Best For
Mentaya
Out-of-network therapists wanting free claims submission; Practices seeking guaranteed claim success or refund; Therapists wanting to offer OON benefits without superbills
American Professional Agency
LCSWs, LMFTs, and LPCs seeking competitive rates; Clinicians with multiple licenses or specialties; Group practices needing entity coverage

Pricing

Starting Price
Free for therapists
~$140/year
Starting Price
Mentaya
Free for therapists
American Professional Agency
~$140/year
Pricing Model
free
flat-annual
Pricing Model
Mentaya
free
American Professional Agency
flat-annual
Free Trial
Free tier available
No free trial
Free Trial
Mentaya
Free tier available
American Professional Agency
No free trial
Pricing Details
100% free for therapists with no hidden fees. Client fee is 5% per claim (e.g., $200 session = $10 fee). Therapists can absorb the fee to offer free claim submission. 100% refund guarantee if claim cannot be successfully submitted.
Competitive rates with discounts for multiple years, claim-free history, and association memberships. Specialty endorsements available for additional modalities.
Pricing Details
Mentaya
100% free for therapists with no hidden fees. Client fee is 5% per claim (e.g., $200 session = $10 fee). Therapists can absorb the fee to offer free claim submission. 100% refund guarantee if claim cannot be successfully submitted.
American Professional Agency
Competitive rates with discounts for multiple years, claim-free history, and association memberships. Specialty endorsements available for additional modalities.

Compliance & Security

HIPAA Compliant
Yes
No
HIPAA Compliant
Mentaya
Yes
American Professional Agency
No
BAA Available
Yes
No
BAA Available
Mentaya
Yes
American Professional Agency
No
SOC 2 Certified
Unknown
Unknown
SOC 2 Certified
Mentaya
Unknown
American Professional Agency
Unknown
HITRUST Certified
Unknown
Unknown
HITRUST Certified
Mentaya
Unknown
American Professional Agency
Unknown

Features

Mobile App
No
No
Mobile App
Mentaya
No
American Professional Agency
No
Mental Health Specific
Yes
Yes
Mental Health Specific
Mentaya
Yes
American Professional Agency
Yes

Integrations

Total Integrations
3 integrations
None listed
Total Integrations
Mentaya
3 integrations
American Professional Agency
None listed
Clearinghouse
None
None
Clearinghouse
Mentaya
None
American Professional Agency
None

Billing Features

Claims Submission
Yes
No
Claims Submission
Mentaya
Yes
American Professional Agency
No
Eligibility Verification
No
No
Eligibility Verification
Mentaya
No
American Professional Agency
No
ERA Processing
Yes
No
ERA Processing
Mentaya
Yes
American Professional Agency
No

Support & Fit

Practice Sizes
Solo, Small (2-10), Medium (11-50)
Solo, Small (2-10), Medium (11-50)
Practice Sizes
Mentaya
Solo, Small (2-10), Medium (11-50)
American Professional Agency
Solo, Small (2-10), Medium (11-50)
Customer Base
Unknown
Unknown
Customer Base
Mentaya
Unknown
American Professional Agency
Unknown

Ready to Get Started?

Visit these tools to learn more or request a personalized demo.

Try Mentaya
Try American Professional Agency
Browse all tools
Mentaya
American Professional Agency